Seesmic Woes
So I've been playing with some new betas lately. First up is Seesmic, a video conversation beta that people are calling the twitter of video. Right off the bat I'm always curious about new video betas. I'm a video blogger, I've done the tube, operator11, ktye dance etc, why not this new thing called Seesmic.
Not much new. Videos are captured in the browser and part of gigantic thread of hey theres, replies to older videos and those general talking head shots. The biggest problem you have in these video beta sites lately is answering WHY I should do it and giving me easy at a glance understanding of what is happening and sorting of content. Seesmic gives me neither. The massive thread list of videos along the left hand side is just reminding you that you can't keep up with content. I know theres people sneezing on the planet I don't need a minute by hour by day accounting of who sneezed and there's no real part of me that wants to rewind the thread back a few dozen pages and see who sneezed yesterday at about 2:35pm. I don't care. Even then if I did care, how can find stuff easily? Nothings sortable, I tried to look for replies to my own videos, I couldn't easily do it, I had to flip down page after page after page to try and find my subject header. This started me thinking that the best way to see at glance replies to your post is to make sure your post has a very unique visual identifier like 44444ASS CAT or !!!!! YOHO or something. Otherwise you find yourself retracing back to previous pages thinking wait a sec, did I miss something?
I suppose Seesmic could care less about what happened 20 mins ago. Many of these new kinds of twitter done in a different way type sites are pushing the idea of conversational blasting, its the pulse of the current moment that really matters nothing else. But its pretty easy to write interesting analytical tools for twitter content and search and sort it out, its impossible to do that with Seesmic.
Seesmic gives you the basics, ya get a profile, you can follow someone, they can follow you, but you can't follow threads you create. That seems whacked.
There's a bit of self love in Seesmic too with the idea that you can follow the makers of the site as they try to make the site successful. That's not really a new trend, thats more of a plea in "use me!!".
Settings in Seesmic allows me to dial out all the languages I don't want to watch, but when ya do that, I dunno, part of me thinks yer kinda modifiying the conversation. Its basically saying you can toss out half of the data in regards to this context. Most of the folks in other countries still speak english or broken english, they are just recording the video from France etc. So why toss out that video unless you absolutely have to. Maybe those settings are there for sheer paranoia? I dunno.
Another thing that gets me is that there's a tab for "shows". Wait a sec, what's that, we have this big conversation thread here, the main piece of the puzzle and then you got youtube video like show section? I don't understand why its there.
If anything Seesmic reminds me of work, cause I'll have to dig to find anything I really want to find. There's no tag cloud, catagories, most watched, most embedded, linked, commented, etc, none of that, every video has the same weight as another.
Video quality is subpar. May not be the sites fault per say since we haven't evolved the webcam yet, but still, quality could be better.
Overall I'm confused by Seesmic and I don't find myself drawn to it. Its basically visual IRC, and if you knew anything about IRC it really did well for the people who didnt have jobs and could chat all day long. IRC was internet relay chat, came before IM even. Its the old school chat room affect. Expect theres no chat rooms in Seesmic, its all one big conversation, and its great if you are posting 100 videos a day, one every 34 seconds to keep up with whatever people are talking about. Those of you that have to work, yer out of the loop, 8 hours away from Seesmic is like 10 pages of content to fumble through and in internet time like 5 days.
Tags: seesmic
Powered by Qumana